User involvement in the encounter between the patient with mental illness and the health care system: the meaning of e-health

Research output: ThesisPh.D. thesis

50 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: In all areas of healthcare, the use of e-health has grown rapidly during the last two decades, especially after the COVID-19 pandemic entered the scene in 2020. One of the areas where e-health has been used even more during the pandemic is mental healthcare. The potential of e-health for treating severe mental illness is demonstrated by positive results regarding medi-cation adherence, symptom severity, cognitive therapy, and hospi-talisation length. Numerous studies indicate that e-health has po-tential for adjunctive use with more conventional mental health treatments. In addition, studies have shown that patients perceive e-health treatment as helpful to enabling flexible communication with healthcare professionals and to motivate patients to be in-volved in their treatment. However, for treatment to be efficient, it is paramount for patients to be engaged, experience a trusting relationship with their healthcare professional, and feel recog-nised. For a successful implementation of e-health treatment, it is crucial that patients find the e-health solution useful and experi-ence being involved in its use; thus, patients’ experience of the use of e-health in their everyday lives and treatment is important.

Aim: This PhD project has aimed to explore how user involvement is constituted in the encounter between patients with mental ill-ness, and mental healthcare services, when e-health is used, in-cluding different opinions on and possible impacts of user in-volvement. The focus is on patients with mental illness and how they use e-health services in collaboration with healthcare profes-sionals.

Methods: This thesis has included a systematic review and two exploratory studies to explore its aim. Study 1 was conducted as a systematic review to explore how patients with severe mental ill-ness experience the role of e-health in their treatment. To be eligi-ble, studies were required to include people between 18 and 65 years old with mental illness, defined as depression, anxiety, bipo-lar disorder, schizophrenia, or personality disorder. An additional criterion for inclusion was that patients’ experiences with tele-health solutions were reported. Three databases, Embase, MED-LINE, and PsycINFO, were searched between April 5, 2020, and June 29, 2020 (renewed November 10, 2021). The included stud-ies were critically appraised using the CASP checklists. Study 2 was a qualitative exploratory study that collected data via repeat individual interviews with a social phenomenological approach, to explore patients’ views on e-health solutions. Inclusion criteria were: patients 18 to 65 years old, diagnosed with severe mental illness (schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or depression), using an e-health solution in collaboration with a healthcare professional. Eight participants were included, and the interviews lasted be-tween 20 and 70 minutes; interviews were audio recorded and transcribed afterwards. Study 3 applied a variety of qualitative methods to explore healthcare professionals’ use of e-health solu-tions in treatment, combining observations, unstructured inter-views and conversations with healthcare professionals. All includ-ed treatment sites (n = 3) used e-health, mostly apps, in their treatment practices, to connect with patients and help them estab-lish structure, or help them navigate their days. This study includ-ed 10 participants between 35 and 61 years old; all were nurses, nursing assistants or social workers, hereafter referred to as healthcare professionals.

Results: E-health has been widely considered to offer a large po-tential to help with aspects of treatment that patients had previ-ously found highly challenging without e-health solutions. The participants used e-health solutions in very different ways and assigned it different values related to their treatment. Regarding face-to-face versus online treatment, all three studies indicate that participants found in-person meetings to be superior. However, flexibility and adaptability in using e-health solutions when they suited patient schedules were among the factors that contributed to patient engagement. The tracking features of the e-health solu-tions also contributed to improved knowledge and collaboration around patients’ conditions and illnesses. In addition, the relation-ship with the healthcare professional had a key role in patient ac-ceptance of e-health solutions. Patients were more willing to let healthcare professionals push them to uphold their end of agree-ments because the e-health solutions provided structured remind-ers. All participants reported that they considered involvement in treatment to be highly important, and the use of e-health solutions increased patients’ experiences of being involved in and feeling in control of their treatment. Healthcare professionals reported need-ing in-person meetings when commencing a new patient relation-ship, to create an adequate foundation to help the relationship flourish and work effectively via e-health solutions.

Conclusion: This study finds that the use of e-health solutions for treating mental illnesses offers an option to be involved and en-gage patients in their own treatment if e-health is used on their terms and in collaboration with a healthcare professional they trust.
Translated title of the contributionBrugerinddragelse i mødet mellem patienten med psykisk sygdom og sundhedsvæsenet: betydningen af ​​e-health
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • University of Southern Denmark
Supervisors/Advisors
  • Nørgaard, Birgitte, Principal supervisor
  • Klausen, Søren Harnow, Co-supervisor
  • Petersen, Esben N., Co-supervisor
  • Lee, Kim, Co-supervisor
Date of defence16. Nov 2023
Publisher
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 26. Oct 2023

Note re. dissertation

Print copy of the full thesis is restricted to reference use in the library.

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'User involvement in the encounter between the patient with mental illness and the health care system: the meaning of e-health'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this