Is the ugly duckling a hero?

Philosophical inquiry as an approach to Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tales in Danish primary school teaching

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Hans Christian Andersen is a cultural icon, and his fairy tales are famous around the world. But despite the positive ring to this description, his status as a canonized author poses a challenge when he is passed on to new generations of readers. In this article, we show examples of how this challenge reveals itself in Danish primary school teaching where Andersen is an obligatory figure in the subject Danish in which he is frequently framed as a national romantic author of morally unambiguous texts. Taking the current use of “The Ugly Duckling” (1844) in primary school teaching materials as a point of departure, we aim to show Andersen’s potential to be presented as an element in primary school teaching that draws on dialogic inquiries rooted in Philosophy with Children. Philosophical inquiries are characterized by an open mindset that incite teachers as well as school children to engage with the rich ethical themes and literary qualities of Andersen’s fairy tales. We conclude the article with our own inquiry manual to “The Ugly Duckling” to illustrate a way to overcome the current hegemonic framing of Andersen and reopen his fairy tale for future discussions and interpretations.
Original languageEnglish
JournalForum for World Literature Studies
Volume11
Issue number2
Pages (from-to)226-241
ISSN1949-8519
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

primary school teaching
fairy tale
teaching materials
schoolchild
interpretation
teacher
Philosophical Inquiry
Fairytales
Primary School
Hans Christian Andersen
Teaching
Hero

Keywords

  • Cultural studies
  • Hans Christian Andersen
  • Philosophy with Children

Cite this

@article{e07b73dbc1be41fba380a72bc5ccbbfb,
title = "Is the ugly duckling a hero?: Philosophical inquiry as an approach to Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tales in Danish primary school teaching",
abstract = "Hans Christian Andersen is a cultural icon, and his fairy tales are famous around the world. But despite the positive ring to this description, his status as a canonized author poses a challenge when he is passed on to new generations of readers. In this article, we show examples of how this challenge reveals itself in Danish primary school teaching where Andersen is an obligatory figure in the subject Danish in which he is frequently framed as a national romantic author of morally unambiguous texts. Taking the current use of “The Ugly Duckling” (1844) in primary school teaching materials as a point of departure, we aim to show Andersen’s potential to be presented as an element in primary school teaching that draws on dialogic inquiries rooted in Philosophy with Children. Philosophical inquiries are characterized by an open mindset that incite teachers as well as school children to engage with the rich ethical themes and literary qualities of Andersen’s fairy tales. We conclude the article with our own inquiry manual to “The Ugly Duckling” to illustrate a way to overcome the current hegemonic framing of Andersen and reopen his fairy tale for future discussions and interpretations.",
keywords = "Cultural studies, Hans Christian Andersen, Philosophy with Children",
author = "Bom, {Anne Klara} and {Schaffalitzky de Muckadell}, Caroline",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
pages = "226--241",
journal = "Forum for World Literature Studies",
issn = "1949-8519",
publisher = "RichardNie, Ed. & Pub.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Is the ugly duckling a hero?

T2 - Philosophical inquiry as an approach to Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tales in Danish primary school teaching

AU - Bom, Anne Klara

AU - Schaffalitzky de Muckadell, Caroline

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Hans Christian Andersen is a cultural icon, and his fairy tales are famous around the world. But despite the positive ring to this description, his status as a canonized author poses a challenge when he is passed on to new generations of readers. In this article, we show examples of how this challenge reveals itself in Danish primary school teaching where Andersen is an obligatory figure in the subject Danish in which he is frequently framed as a national romantic author of morally unambiguous texts. Taking the current use of “The Ugly Duckling” (1844) in primary school teaching materials as a point of departure, we aim to show Andersen’s potential to be presented as an element in primary school teaching that draws on dialogic inquiries rooted in Philosophy with Children. Philosophical inquiries are characterized by an open mindset that incite teachers as well as school children to engage with the rich ethical themes and literary qualities of Andersen’s fairy tales. We conclude the article with our own inquiry manual to “The Ugly Duckling” to illustrate a way to overcome the current hegemonic framing of Andersen and reopen his fairy tale for future discussions and interpretations.

AB - Hans Christian Andersen is a cultural icon, and his fairy tales are famous around the world. But despite the positive ring to this description, his status as a canonized author poses a challenge when he is passed on to new generations of readers. In this article, we show examples of how this challenge reveals itself in Danish primary school teaching where Andersen is an obligatory figure in the subject Danish in which he is frequently framed as a national romantic author of morally unambiguous texts. Taking the current use of “The Ugly Duckling” (1844) in primary school teaching materials as a point of departure, we aim to show Andersen’s potential to be presented as an element in primary school teaching that draws on dialogic inquiries rooted in Philosophy with Children. Philosophical inquiries are characterized by an open mindset that incite teachers as well as school children to engage with the rich ethical themes and literary qualities of Andersen’s fairy tales. We conclude the article with our own inquiry manual to “The Ugly Duckling” to illustrate a way to overcome the current hegemonic framing of Andersen and reopen his fairy tale for future discussions and interpretations.

KW - Cultural studies

KW - Hans Christian Andersen

KW - Philosophy with Children

M3 - Journal article

VL - 11

SP - 226

EP - 241

JO - Forum for World Literature Studies

JF - Forum for World Literature Studies

SN - 1949-8519

IS - 2

ER -