TY - GEN
T1 - Exploring Artificial Intelligence in International Relations: Technologies, Practices, and Status
AU - Nadibaidze, Anna
PY - 2024/5/8
Y1 - 2024/5/8
N2 - Scholars, experts, policymakers, and industry actors associate artificial intelligence (AI) technologies with significant changes happening across various spheres, including in international politics and security. Following the commonly held perceptions that AI is deeply transformative or a source of power, many argue that states are pursuing AI to seize the economic, political, security, and societal opportunities it is expected to bring, as well as to gain a higher standing in the so-called global ‘AI race’. Such ways of thinking about AI in global politics follow the ‘conventional’ way of theorizing technology in International Relations (IR) literature, i.e., portraying technology as an external factor to social processes, either as 1) an independent or intervening variable leading to effects over which we have no control (based on technological determinism), or 2) an instrument or tool used by actors to solve a problem or achieve their political/military objectives (based on instrumentalism). However, these perspectives provide only a limited analytical toolbox at a time when we need to understand the global social context of why and how states pursue AI.
Building upon scholarship in social constructivism and Science and Technology Studies (STS) in IR, this dissertation argues for conceptualizing the development of AI technologies as deeply embedded in and co-constituted by the quest for status and identity, a key social process in global politics. Based on insights from these perspectives, this research highlights the need to understand states’ practices surrounding AI development, including in the military and security domains, as social. States’ practices in relation to AI technologies deserve to be examined as part of their quest for status, defined in this dissertation as the pursuit of a secure identity. The dissertation comprises of four articles, each exploring different sets of practices through which states can pursue AI technologies, with an overall empirical focus on Russia. Article 1 demonstrates how Russia’s self-identification as a great power enables its diplomatic practices on weaponized AI and autonomous weapon systems at the United Nations. Article 2 dives into the Russian leadership’s official narrative on AI, a narrative in both textual and visual form acting as a cognitive tool in Russia’s quest for ontological security, or its security of the self, in relation to its self-attributed great power status. Article 3 focuses on how states demonstrate their algorithmic warfare capabilities via visual practices, composed of two layers (visual and discursive), which combined have the potential of reinforcing certain ways of imagining AI technologies in the military sphere and of fueling misperceptions in social relations. Article 4, co-authored with Nicolò Miotto, compares US and Russian official discourses on AI and showcases the importance of examining these discursive practices, as well as their social context, to understand the impact of AI on strategic stability.
Taken together, these four articles form the three main takeaways and contributions of this dissertation. First, this dissertation shows that we can conceptualize the relationship between status in IR and various practices surrounding AI as part of a complex socio-technical system. In this complex system, states’ quest for status and identity can enable certain AI-related practices, but also practices can be embedded in, make up, and affect states’ performances of their status and self-perceived identity. Second, this dissertation demonstrates the variety of practices through which states can pursue AI technologies, and how these sets of routinized sayings and doings make up states’ performances of how they see themselves and want to be seen by others. While the four articles focus on diplomatic, discursive, narrative, and visual sets of practices, the dissertation shows the potential of different types of empirical data to analyze states’ practices in the sphere of AI development, especially when the latter is thought of as a complex socio-technical system. Third, this dissertation highlights how some of these practices can potentially affect international dynamics of AI development by reinforcing certain (mis)perceptions, fueling uncertainty, or exacerbating existing social processes, including the pursuit of status and identity.
AB - Scholars, experts, policymakers, and industry actors associate artificial intelligence (AI) technologies with significant changes happening across various spheres, including in international politics and security. Following the commonly held perceptions that AI is deeply transformative or a source of power, many argue that states are pursuing AI to seize the economic, political, security, and societal opportunities it is expected to bring, as well as to gain a higher standing in the so-called global ‘AI race’. Such ways of thinking about AI in global politics follow the ‘conventional’ way of theorizing technology in International Relations (IR) literature, i.e., portraying technology as an external factor to social processes, either as 1) an independent or intervening variable leading to effects over which we have no control (based on technological determinism), or 2) an instrument or tool used by actors to solve a problem or achieve their political/military objectives (based on instrumentalism). However, these perspectives provide only a limited analytical toolbox at a time when we need to understand the global social context of why and how states pursue AI.
Building upon scholarship in social constructivism and Science and Technology Studies (STS) in IR, this dissertation argues for conceptualizing the development of AI technologies as deeply embedded in and co-constituted by the quest for status and identity, a key social process in global politics. Based on insights from these perspectives, this research highlights the need to understand states’ practices surrounding AI development, including in the military and security domains, as social. States’ practices in relation to AI technologies deserve to be examined as part of their quest for status, defined in this dissertation as the pursuit of a secure identity. The dissertation comprises of four articles, each exploring different sets of practices through which states can pursue AI technologies, with an overall empirical focus on Russia. Article 1 demonstrates how Russia’s self-identification as a great power enables its diplomatic practices on weaponized AI and autonomous weapon systems at the United Nations. Article 2 dives into the Russian leadership’s official narrative on AI, a narrative in both textual and visual form acting as a cognitive tool in Russia’s quest for ontological security, or its security of the self, in relation to its self-attributed great power status. Article 3 focuses on how states demonstrate their algorithmic warfare capabilities via visual practices, composed of two layers (visual and discursive), which combined have the potential of reinforcing certain ways of imagining AI technologies in the military sphere and of fueling misperceptions in social relations. Article 4, co-authored with Nicolò Miotto, compares US and Russian official discourses on AI and showcases the importance of examining these discursive practices, as well as their social context, to understand the impact of AI on strategic stability.
Taken together, these four articles form the three main takeaways and contributions of this dissertation. First, this dissertation shows that we can conceptualize the relationship between status in IR and various practices surrounding AI as part of a complex socio-technical system. In this complex system, states’ quest for status and identity can enable certain AI-related practices, but also practices can be embedded in, make up, and affect states’ performances of their status and self-perceived identity. Second, this dissertation demonstrates the variety of practices through which states can pursue AI technologies, and how these sets of routinized sayings and doings make up states’ performances of how they see themselves and want to be seen by others. While the four articles focus on diplomatic, discursive, narrative, and visual sets of practices, the dissertation shows the potential of different types of empirical data to analyze states’ practices in the sphere of AI development, especially when the latter is thought of as a complex socio-technical system. Third, this dissertation highlights how some of these practices can potentially affect international dynamics of AI development by reinforcing certain (mis)perceptions, fueling uncertainty, or exacerbating existing social processes, including the pursuit of status and identity.
KW - artificial intelligence
KW - technology
KW - international relations
KW - status
KW - state identity
KW - practices
KW - Russia
U2 - 10.21996/wm0e-w770
DO - 10.21996/wm0e-w770
M3 - Ph.D. thesis
PB - Syddansk Universitet. Det Samfundsvidenskabelige Fakultet
ER -