Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Innovation in sport and movement has established itself as a multidisciplinary practice in which part of the innovations are various digital artefacts supporting physical activity, also termed movement games. In this empirical and philosophical study, we examine a multitude of value stances on an ethical-aesthetic continuum. Value stances are defined as philosophically embracing virtues, values, logics or lenses. We find that balancing the multitude of ethical-aesthetical value stances and with respect to “the purposefulness of no purpose” in doing sport, play, and physical movement, is vital in designing sustainable movement-games. Using artefacts such as heart rate monitors, GPS trackers, and other fitness trackers all acts for the quantifiable self. Similarly, mobile games, exergames, exertion-games, and play installations for physical activity have found their way into private and public spaces. These movement-games have a somewhat utilitarian user approach often designed mainly for health gains, not harvesting the full potential of seeing the users as social and physical moving human existences. This restricted user approach raises the question; what value stances may enhance the design of sustainable movement-games? The Danish existentialist philosopher Søren Kierkegaard stated that the aesthetic dimension denotes that humans strive to perform and feel well and to have pleasurable experiences. The ethical dimension refers to the human aspiration to do good based on interhuman normative standards. In our contemporary society we aim mainly at the aesthetic – pleasurable experiences – and perhaps too little "being" – "as an ethical dimension of life". The analysis in this paper takes its point of departure in sport and health students’ reflections on their stances of doing movement and, further, their forming of value stances for five different proto-personas. The identified value stances that we merged into ten value stances unfolded in an ethical-aesthetic continuum. The identified value stances are; Fellowship, Empathy, Recognition, Play, Compete, Fun & Happiness, Mastery, Self-realisation, Health, and Immersion. The value stances are discussed by drawing on previous work on virtues and lenses in creating movement-games. In conclusion, we propose four distinct movement and design recommendations that we find valuable to include in the development of digital movement-games.

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019
EditorsLars Elbaek, Gunver Majgaard, Andrea Valente, Saifuddin Khalid
PublisherDECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology
Publication dateOct 2019
Pages210-217
ISBN (Electronic)9781912764389
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2019
Event13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019 - Odense, Denmark
Duration: 3. Oct 20194. Oct 2019

Conference

Conference13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019
CountryDenmark
CityOdense
Period03/10/201904/10/2019
SeriesProceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning
Volume2019-October
ISSN2049-0992

Fingerprint

aesthetics
Sports
Values
artifact
health
innovation
self-realization
happiness
fitness
public space
empathy
experience

Keywords

  • Digital design
  • Digital movement games
  • Human physical movement
  • Philosophy
  • Sport services
  • Stances
  • Virtues

Cite this

Elbæk, L., & Hansen, R. E. (2019). Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games. In L. Elbaek, G. Majgaard, A. Valente, & S. Khalid (Eds.), Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019 (pp. 210-217). DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology. Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning, Vol.. 2019-October https://doi.org/10.34190/GBL.19.181
Elbæk, Lars ; Hansen, René Engelhardt. / Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games. Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019. editor / Lars Elbaek ; Gunver Majgaard ; Andrea Valente ; Saifuddin Khalid. DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology, 2019. pp. 210-217 (Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning, Vol. 2019-October).
@inproceedings{cbed5b907c2d4ad3ba33800f82a4f50b,
title = "Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games",
abstract = "Innovation in sport and movement has established itself as a multidisciplinary practice in which part of the innovations are various digital artefacts supporting physical activity, also termed movement games. In this empirical and philosophical study, we examine a multitude of value stances on an ethical-aesthetic continuum. Value stances are defined as philosophically embracing virtues, values, logics or lenses. We find that balancing the multitude of ethical-aesthetical value stances and with respect to “the purposefulness of no purpose” in doing sport, play, and physical movement, is vital in designing sustainable movement-games. Using artefacts such as heart rate monitors, GPS trackers, and other fitness trackers all acts for the quantifiable self. Similarly, mobile games, exergames, exertion-games, and play installations for physical activity have found their way into private and public spaces. These movement-games have a somewhat utilitarian user approach often designed mainly for health gains, not harvesting the full potential of seeing the users as social and physical moving human existences. This restricted user approach raises the question; what value stances may enhance the design of sustainable movement-games? The Danish existentialist philosopher S{\o}ren Kierkegaard stated that the aesthetic dimension denotes that humans strive to perform and feel well and to have pleasurable experiences. The ethical dimension refers to the human aspiration to do good based on interhuman normative standards. In our contemporary society we aim mainly at the aesthetic – pleasurable experiences – and perhaps too little {"}being{"} – {"}as an ethical dimension of life{"}. The analysis in this paper takes its point of departure in sport and health students’ reflections on their stances of doing movement and, further, their forming of value stances for five different proto-personas. The identified value stances that we merged into ten value stances unfolded in an ethical-aesthetic continuum. The identified value stances are; Fellowship, Empathy, Recognition, Play, Compete, Fun & Happiness, Mastery, Self-realisation, Health, and Immersion. The value stances are discussed by drawing on previous work on virtues and lenses in creating movement-games. In conclusion, we propose four distinct movement and design recommendations that we find valuable to include in the development of digital movement-games.",
keywords = "Digital design, Digital movement games, Human physical movement, Philosophy, Sport services, Stances, Virtues",
author = "Lars Elb{\ae}k and Hansen, {Ren{\'e} Engelhardt}",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
doi = "10.34190/GBL.19.181",
language = "English",
series = "Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning",
pages = "210--217",
editor = "Lars Elbaek and Gunver Majgaard and Andrea Valente and Saifuddin Khalid",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019",
publisher = "DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology",

}

Elbæk, L & Hansen, RE 2019, Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games. in L Elbaek, G Majgaard, A Valente & S Khalid (eds), Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019. DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology, Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning, vol. 2019-October, pp. 210-217, 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019, Odense, Denmark, 03/10/2019. https://doi.org/10.34190/GBL.19.181

Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games. / Elbæk, Lars; Hansen, René Engelhardt.

Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019. ed. / Lars Elbaek; Gunver Majgaard; Andrea Valente; Saifuddin Khalid. DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology, 2019. p. 210-217 (Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning, Vol. 2019-October).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games

AU - Elbæk, Lars

AU - Hansen, René Engelhardt

PY - 2019/10

Y1 - 2019/10

N2 - Innovation in sport and movement has established itself as a multidisciplinary practice in which part of the innovations are various digital artefacts supporting physical activity, also termed movement games. In this empirical and philosophical study, we examine a multitude of value stances on an ethical-aesthetic continuum. Value stances are defined as philosophically embracing virtues, values, logics or lenses. We find that balancing the multitude of ethical-aesthetical value stances and with respect to “the purposefulness of no purpose” in doing sport, play, and physical movement, is vital in designing sustainable movement-games. Using artefacts such as heart rate monitors, GPS trackers, and other fitness trackers all acts for the quantifiable self. Similarly, mobile games, exergames, exertion-games, and play installations for physical activity have found their way into private and public spaces. These movement-games have a somewhat utilitarian user approach often designed mainly for health gains, not harvesting the full potential of seeing the users as social and physical moving human existences. This restricted user approach raises the question; what value stances may enhance the design of sustainable movement-games? The Danish existentialist philosopher Søren Kierkegaard stated that the aesthetic dimension denotes that humans strive to perform and feel well and to have pleasurable experiences. The ethical dimension refers to the human aspiration to do good based on interhuman normative standards. In our contemporary society we aim mainly at the aesthetic – pleasurable experiences – and perhaps too little "being" – "as an ethical dimension of life". The analysis in this paper takes its point of departure in sport and health students’ reflections on their stances of doing movement and, further, their forming of value stances for five different proto-personas. The identified value stances that we merged into ten value stances unfolded in an ethical-aesthetic continuum. The identified value stances are; Fellowship, Empathy, Recognition, Play, Compete, Fun & Happiness, Mastery, Self-realisation, Health, and Immersion. The value stances are discussed by drawing on previous work on virtues and lenses in creating movement-games. In conclusion, we propose four distinct movement and design recommendations that we find valuable to include in the development of digital movement-games.

AB - Innovation in sport and movement has established itself as a multidisciplinary practice in which part of the innovations are various digital artefacts supporting physical activity, also termed movement games. In this empirical and philosophical study, we examine a multitude of value stances on an ethical-aesthetic continuum. Value stances are defined as philosophically embracing virtues, values, logics or lenses. We find that balancing the multitude of ethical-aesthetical value stances and with respect to “the purposefulness of no purpose” in doing sport, play, and physical movement, is vital in designing sustainable movement-games. Using artefacts such as heart rate monitors, GPS trackers, and other fitness trackers all acts for the quantifiable self. Similarly, mobile games, exergames, exertion-games, and play installations for physical activity have found their way into private and public spaces. These movement-games have a somewhat utilitarian user approach often designed mainly for health gains, not harvesting the full potential of seeing the users as social and physical moving human existences. This restricted user approach raises the question; what value stances may enhance the design of sustainable movement-games? The Danish existentialist philosopher Søren Kierkegaard stated that the aesthetic dimension denotes that humans strive to perform and feel well and to have pleasurable experiences. The ethical dimension refers to the human aspiration to do good based on interhuman normative standards. In our contemporary society we aim mainly at the aesthetic – pleasurable experiences – and perhaps too little "being" – "as an ethical dimension of life". The analysis in this paper takes its point of departure in sport and health students’ reflections on their stances of doing movement and, further, their forming of value stances for five different proto-personas. The identified value stances that we merged into ten value stances unfolded in an ethical-aesthetic continuum. The identified value stances are; Fellowship, Empathy, Recognition, Play, Compete, Fun & Happiness, Mastery, Self-realisation, Health, and Immersion. The value stances are discussed by drawing on previous work on virtues and lenses in creating movement-games. In conclusion, we propose four distinct movement and design recommendations that we find valuable to include in the development of digital movement-games.

KW - Digital design

KW - Digital movement games

KW - Human physical movement

KW - Philosophy

KW - Sport services

KW - Stances

KW - Virtues

U2 - 10.34190/GBL.19.181

DO - 10.34190/GBL.19.181

M3 - Article in proceedings

AN - SCOPUS:85075272391

T3 - Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning

SP - 210

EP - 217

BT - Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019

A2 - Elbaek, Lars

A2 - Majgaard, Gunver

A2 - Valente, Andrea

A2 - Khalid, Saifuddin

PB - DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology

ER -

Elbæk L, Hansen RE. Aesthetic and ethical value stances in sport, play, and movement-games. In Elbaek L, Majgaard G, Valente A, Khalid S, editors, Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Game Based Learning, ECGBL 2019. DECHEMA e.V., Society for Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology. 2019. p. 210-217. (Proceedings of the European Conference on Games-based Learning, Vol. 2019-October). https://doi.org/10.34190/GBL.19.181