A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria

Mette Jessen Schultz, Henrik Tønder Aabjerg Friis, Zheng Ma, Bo Nørregaard Jørgensen

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

Abstract

The energy sector is undergoing a green transition which entails the challenge of balancing electricity demand and supply. A way to deal with this problem is to make the electricity demand flexible by introducing demand response, which leads to new business opportunities and stakeholders in the market. Furthermore, the business opportunities for demand response and new stakeholders, like the so called aggregators (a service company that pools flexibility from customers and converts it into electricity market services), are strongly influenced by national and international policies and regulation.Therefore, this paper aims to investigate the business opportunities of aggregators and how aggregators, in the smart energy business ecosystem, are influenced by the changes in policy and regulation.

This research examines two case studies, Denmark and Austria. With qualitative research on several stakeholders in the smart energy ecosystem, a cross-national comparative study investigates the similarities and differences of policy and regulation related to the business opportunities for the aggregators in the demand response.

This research finds that the climate goals, regulation of energy prices and market structure are factors that are influenced by policy and regulation and will influence the adoption success rate of demand response most. The two ecosystems have many similarities, but also disparities.

Currently, it is legally possible to enter the electricity market with the aggregated demand response in both countries, however, it only happens in Austria and not in Denmark.

The main differences between the two energy systems are the ambitious Danish climate plan to make Denmark carbon neutral by 2050 and the flexible tariffs in Austria to make the grid congestion visible to the consumers. Also, electrification and sector coupling should be considered to optimize the business opportunities for the demand response. The results of this research contribute to understanding the political and regulatory factors which influence the adoption of demand response under different national frames and help smart energy market players to predict market opportunities and challenges in the future European energy sector.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency : Is Efficient Sufficient?
PublisherEuropean Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE)
Publication date2019
Pages541-549
ISBN (Print)978-91-983878-4-1
ISBN (Electronic)978-91-983878-5-8
Publication statusPublished - 2019
EventECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency - Presqu’île de Giens, Hyères, France
Duration: 3. Jun 20198. Jun 2019
https://www.eceee.org/static/media/uploads/site-2/summerstudy2019/Brochures_programme_etc/abstracts_2019.pdf

Conference

ConferenceECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency
LocationPresqu’île de Giens
CountryFrance
CityHyères
Period03/06/201908/06/2019
Internet address

Fingerprint

Austria
Comparative study
Demand response
Cross-national
Denmark
Stakeholders
Electricity market
Energy sector
Ecosystem
Energy market
Climate
Energy
Electricity demand
Energy prices
International regulation
Electricity supply
Factors
International policy
Influence factors
Grid

Cite this

Schultz, M. J., Aabjerg Friis, H. T., Ma, Z., & Jørgensen, B. N. (2019). A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria. In ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency: Is Efficient Sufficient? (pp. 541-549). European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE).
Schultz, Mette Jessen ; Aabjerg Friis, Henrik Tønder ; Ma, Zheng ; Jørgensen, Bo Nørregaard. / A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria. ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency: Is Efficient Sufficient?. European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE), 2019. pp. 541-549
@inproceedings{daac734a391f4e2192a6c3d035b5a17c,
title = "A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria",
abstract = "The energy sector is undergoing a green transition which entails the challenge of balancing electricity demand and supply. A way to deal with this problem is to make the electricity demand flexible by introducing demand response, which leads to new business opportunities and stakeholders in the market. Furthermore, the business opportunities for demand response and new stakeholders, like the so called aggregators (a service company that pools flexibility from customers and converts it into electricity market services), are strongly influenced by national and international policies and regulation.Therefore, this paper aims to investigate the business opportunities of aggregators and how aggregators, in the smart energy business ecosystem, are influenced by the changes in policy and regulation.This research examines two case studies, Denmark and Austria. With qualitative research on several stakeholders in the smart energy ecosystem, a cross-national comparative study investigates the similarities and differences of policy and regulation related to the business opportunities for the aggregators in the demand response.This research finds that the climate goals, regulation of energy prices and market structure are factors that are influenced by policy and regulation and will influence the adoption success rate of demand response most. The two ecosystems have many similarities, but also disparities.Currently, it is legally possible to enter the electricity market with the aggregated demand response in both countries, however, it only happens in Austria and not in Denmark.The main differences between the two energy systems are the ambitious Danish climate plan to make Denmark carbon neutral by 2050 and the flexible tariffs in Austria to make the grid congestion visible to the consumers. Also, electrification and sector coupling should be considered to optimize the business opportunities for the demand response. The results of this research contribute to understanding the political and regulatory factors which influence the adoption of demand response under different national frames and help smart energy market players to predict market opportunities and challenges in the future European energy sector.",
author = "Schultz, {Mette Jessen} and {Aabjerg Friis}, {Henrik T{\o}nder} and Zheng Ma and J{\o}rgensen, {Bo N{\o}rregaard}",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-91-983878-4-1",
pages = "541--549",
booktitle = "ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency",
publisher = "European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE)",

}

Schultz, MJ, Aabjerg Friis, HT, Ma, Z & Jørgensen, BN 2019, A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria. in ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency: Is Efficient Sufficient?. European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE), pp. 541-549, ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency, Hyères, France, 03/06/2019.

A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria. / Schultz, Mette Jessen; Aabjerg Friis, Henrik Tønder; Ma, Zheng; Jørgensen, Bo Nørregaard.

ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency: Is Efficient Sufficient?. European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE), 2019. p. 541-549.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingArticle in proceedingsResearchpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria

AU - Schultz, Mette Jessen

AU - Aabjerg Friis, Henrik Tønder

AU - Ma, Zheng

AU - Jørgensen, Bo Nørregaard

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - The energy sector is undergoing a green transition which entails the challenge of balancing electricity demand and supply. A way to deal with this problem is to make the electricity demand flexible by introducing demand response, which leads to new business opportunities and stakeholders in the market. Furthermore, the business opportunities for demand response and new stakeholders, like the so called aggregators (a service company that pools flexibility from customers and converts it into electricity market services), are strongly influenced by national and international policies and regulation.Therefore, this paper aims to investigate the business opportunities of aggregators and how aggregators, in the smart energy business ecosystem, are influenced by the changes in policy and regulation.This research examines two case studies, Denmark and Austria. With qualitative research on several stakeholders in the smart energy ecosystem, a cross-national comparative study investigates the similarities and differences of policy and regulation related to the business opportunities for the aggregators in the demand response.This research finds that the climate goals, regulation of energy prices and market structure are factors that are influenced by policy and regulation and will influence the adoption success rate of demand response most. The two ecosystems have many similarities, but also disparities.Currently, it is legally possible to enter the electricity market with the aggregated demand response in both countries, however, it only happens in Austria and not in Denmark.The main differences between the two energy systems are the ambitious Danish climate plan to make Denmark carbon neutral by 2050 and the flexible tariffs in Austria to make the grid congestion visible to the consumers. Also, electrification and sector coupling should be considered to optimize the business opportunities for the demand response. The results of this research contribute to understanding the political and regulatory factors which influence the adoption of demand response under different national frames and help smart energy market players to predict market opportunities and challenges in the future European energy sector.

AB - The energy sector is undergoing a green transition which entails the challenge of balancing electricity demand and supply. A way to deal with this problem is to make the electricity demand flexible by introducing demand response, which leads to new business opportunities and stakeholders in the market. Furthermore, the business opportunities for demand response and new stakeholders, like the so called aggregators (a service company that pools flexibility from customers and converts it into electricity market services), are strongly influenced by national and international policies and regulation.Therefore, this paper aims to investigate the business opportunities of aggregators and how aggregators, in the smart energy business ecosystem, are influenced by the changes in policy and regulation.This research examines two case studies, Denmark and Austria. With qualitative research on several stakeholders in the smart energy ecosystem, a cross-national comparative study investigates the similarities and differences of policy and regulation related to the business opportunities for the aggregators in the demand response.This research finds that the climate goals, regulation of energy prices and market structure are factors that are influenced by policy and regulation and will influence the adoption success rate of demand response most. The two ecosystems have many similarities, but also disparities.Currently, it is legally possible to enter the electricity market with the aggregated demand response in both countries, however, it only happens in Austria and not in Denmark.The main differences between the two energy systems are the ambitious Danish climate plan to make Denmark carbon neutral by 2050 and the flexible tariffs in Austria to make the grid congestion visible to the consumers. Also, electrification and sector coupling should be considered to optimize the business opportunities for the demand response. The results of this research contribute to understanding the political and regulatory factors which influence the adoption of demand response under different national frames and help smart energy market players to predict market opportunities and challenges in the future European energy sector.

M3 - Article in proceedings

SN - 978-91-983878-4-1

SP - 541

EP - 549

BT - ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency

PB - European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE)

ER -

Schultz MJ, Aabjerg Friis HT, Ma Z, Jørgensen BN. A cross-national comparative study of the political and regulatory impact on the adoption of demand response in Denmark and Austria. In ECEEE 2019 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency: Is Efficient Sufficient?. European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy (ECEEE). 2019. p. 541-549