“Hooked up to that damn machine”

Working with metaphors in clinical ethics cases

Susanne Michl*, Anita Wohlmann

*Kontaktforfatter for dette arbejde

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

28 Downloads (Pure)

Resumé

The frequent use of metaphors in health care communication in general and clinical ethics cases in particular calls for a more mindful and competent use of figurative speech. Metaphors are powerful tools that enable different ways of thinking about complex issues in health care. However, depending on how and in which context they are used, they can also be harmful and undermine medical decision-making. Given this contingent nature of metaphors, this article discusses two approaches that suggest how medical health care professionals may systematically and imaginatively work with metaphors. The first approach is informed by a model developed by cognitive scientists George Lakoff and Mark Turner. The second approach is a close reading and thus a text-immanent, hermeneutical strategy. Using the double perspective of an ethics consultant and a researcher in literature studies, we take a case from Richard M Zaner in which a metaphor is central to the clinical-ethical problem. The article shows that the approaches, which focus on creativity and the intersections of form and content, may be helpful tools in clinical ethics, enabling a competent and mindful working with metaphors in complex cases as well as supporting the consultant’s thoughts processes.

OriginalsprogEngelsk
TidsskriftClinical Ethics
Vol/bind14
Udgave nummer2
Sider (fra-til)80-86
ISSN1477-7509
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 1. jun. 2019

Fingeraftryk

Metaphor
Delivery of Health Care
Ethicists
Health Communication
Creativity
Consultants
Clinical Ethics
Reading
Research Personnel
Healthcare

Citer dette

@article{7d481fbb9f48453dbf86978f83246d39,
title = "“Hooked up to that damn machine”: Working with metaphors in clinical ethics cases",
abstract = "The frequent use of metaphors in health care communication in general and clinical ethics cases in particular calls for a more mindful and competent use of figurative speech. Metaphors are powerful tools that enable different ways of thinking about complex issues in health care. However, depending on how and in which context they are used, they can also be harmful and undermine medical decision-making. Given this contingent nature of metaphors, this article discusses two approaches that suggest how medical health care professionals may systematically and imaginatively work with metaphors. The first approach is informed by a model developed by cognitive scientists George Lakoff and Mark Turner. The second approach is a close reading and thus a text-immanent, hermeneutical strategy. Using the double perspective of an ethics consultant and a researcher in literature studies, we take a case from Richard M Zaner in which a metaphor is central to the clinical-ethical problem. The article shows that the approaches, which focus on creativity and the intersections of form and content, may be helpful tools in clinical ethics, enabling a competent and mindful working with metaphors in complex cases as well as supporting the consultant’s thoughts processes.",
keywords = "clinical ethics cases, literature studies, Metaphor, narrative",
author = "Susanne Michl and Anita Wohlmann",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/1477750919851064",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "80--86",
journal = "Clinical Ethics",
issn = "1477-7509",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "2",

}

“Hooked up to that damn machine” : Working with metaphors in clinical ethics cases. / Michl, Susanne; Wohlmann, Anita.

I: Clinical Ethics, Bind 14, Nr. 2, 01.06.2019, s. 80-86.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - “Hooked up to that damn machine”

T2 - Working with metaphors in clinical ethics cases

AU - Michl, Susanne

AU - Wohlmann, Anita

PY - 2019/6/1

Y1 - 2019/6/1

N2 - The frequent use of metaphors in health care communication in general and clinical ethics cases in particular calls for a more mindful and competent use of figurative speech. Metaphors are powerful tools that enable different ways of thinking about complex issues in health care. However, depending on how and in which context they are used, they can also be harmful and undermine medical decision-making. Given this contingent nature of metaphors, this article discusses two approaches that suggest how medical health care professionals may systematically and imaginatively work with metaphors. The first approach is informed by a model developed by cognitive scientists George Lakoff and Mark Turner. The second approach is a close reading and thus a text-immanent, hermeneutical strategy. Using the double perspective of an ethics consultant and a researcher in literature studies, we take a case from Richard M Zaner in which a metaphor is central to the clinical-ethical problem. The article shows that the approaches, which focus on creativity and the intersections of form and content, may be helpful tools in clinical ethics, enabling a competent and mindful working with metaphors in complex cases as well as supporting the consultant’s thoughts processes.

AB - The frequent use of metaphors in health care communication in general and clinical ethics cases in particular calls for a more mindful and competent use of figurative speech. Metaphors are powerful tools that enable different ways of thinking about complex issues in health care. However, depending on how and in which context they are used, they can also be harmful and undermine medical decision-making. Given this contingent nature of metaphors, this article discusses two approaches that suggest how medical health care professionals may systematically and imaginatively work with metaphors. The first approach is informed by a model developed by cognitive scientists George Lakoff and Mark Turner. The second approach is a close reading and thus a text-immanent, hermeneutical strategy. Using the double perspective of an ethics consultant and a researcher in literature studies, we take a case from Richard M Zaner in which a metaphor is central to the clinical-ethical problem. The article shows that the approaches, which focus on creativity and the intersections of form and content, may be helpful tools in clinical ethics, enabling a competent and mindful working with metaphors in complex cases as well as supporting the consultant’s thoughts processes.

KW - clinical ethics cases

KW - literature studies

KW - Metaphor

KW - narrative

U2 - 10.1177/1477750919851064

DO - 10.1177/1477750919851064

M3 - Journal article

VL - 14

SP - 80

EP - 86

JO - Clinical Ethics

JF - Clinical Ethics

SN - 1477-7509

IS - 2

ER -