Governance discourses reflecting tensions in a multifunctional land use system in decay

tradition versus modernity in the Portuguese montado

Teresa Pinto-Correia*, José Muñoz-Rojas, Martin Hvarregaard Thorsøe, Egon Bjørnshave Noe

*Kontaktforfatter for dette arbejde

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

Resumé

The montado is a silvo pastoral system, and the dominant land-use in the region of Alentejo (Portugal). It bears high nature, socio-economic, and landscape values, shaping the strong cultural identity of the region. Despite these values, it has been under decay over the last decades, indicating the inefficiency of current governance strategies. In this paper, we argue how three main discourses can be found that underpin different governance strategies in the montado: The heritage discourse, the modern production discourse, and the land stewardship discourse. These discourses frame farmers' decisions, though not always explicitly. The discourse analysis is grounded on an analysis of the relevant literature and research results from diverse projects, including an analysis of media representation of the montado since the 1990s, participatory observations, and 30 in-depth interviews with key stakeholders. Each of the three discourses identified are characterized in terms of key farming developments and defining elements, their time-scopes, the ways in which they are perceived by society, their measures of success, and underpinning institutions and power mechanisms. We argue that these discourses co-exist today, and this is a cause of increased tensions in montado governance strategies, hindering more effective and sustainable potential alternatives for the system.

OriginalsprogEngelsk
Artikelnummer3363
TidsskriftSustainability (Switzerland)
Vol/bind11
Udgave nummer12
ISSN2071-1050
DOI
StatusUdgivet - 1. jan. 2019

Fingeraftryk

modernity
Land use
land use
governance
Economics
discourse
cultural identity
stakeholder
analysis
research results
discourse analysis
Portugal
Values
farmer
cause
interview
economics

Citer dette

@article{0bd3afeffa414ece887432bbc802992b,
title = "Governance discourses reflecting tensions in a multifunctional land use system in decay: tradition versus modernity in the Portuguese montado",
abstract = "The montado is a silvo pastoral system, and the dominant land-use in the region of Alentejo (Portugal). It bears high nature, socio-economic, and landscape values, shaping the strong cultural identity of the region. Despite these values, it has been under decay over the last decades, indicating the inefficiency of current governance strategies. In this paper, we argue how three main discourses can be found that underpin different governance strategies in the montado: The heritage discourse, the modern production discourse, and the land stewardship discourse. These discourses frame farmers' decisions, though not always explicitly. The discourse analysis is grounded on an analysis of the relevant literature and research results from diverse projects, including an analysis of media representation of the montado since the 1990s, participatory observations, and 30 in-depth interviews with key stakeholders. Each of the three discourses identified are characterized in terms of key farming developments and defining elements, their time-scopes, the ways in which they are perceived by society, their measures of success, and underpinning institutions and power mechanisms. We argue that these discourses co-exist today, and this is a cause of increased tensions in montado governance strategies, hindering more effective and sustainable potential alternatives for the system.",
keywords = "Discourse, Governance, Montado, Multi-functionality, Portugal, Silvo-pastoral system, Tension",
author = "Teresa Pinto-Correia and Jos{\'e} Mu{\~n}oz-Rojas and Thors{\o}e, {Martin Hvarregaard} and Noe, {Egon Bj{\o}rnshave}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3390/su11123363",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
journal = "Sustainability",
issn = "2071-1050",
publisher = "MDPI",
number = "12",

}

Governance discourses reflecting tensions in a multifunctional land use system in decay : tradition versus modernity in the Portuguese montado. / Pinto-Correia, Teresa; Muñoz-Rojas, José; Thorsøe, Martin Hvarregaard; Noe, Egon Bjørnshave.

I: Sustainability (Switzerland), Bind 11, Nr. 12, 3363, 01.01.2019.

Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskriftTidsskriftartikelForskningpeer review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Governance discourses reflecting tensions in a multifunctional land use system in decay

T2 - tradition versus modernity in the Portuguese montado

AU - Pinto-Correia, Teresa

AU - Muñoz-Rojas, José

AU - Thorsøe, Martin Hvarregaard

AU - Noe, Egon Bjørnshave

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - The montado is a silvo pastoral system, and the dominant land-use in the region of Alentejo (Portugal). It bears high nature, socio-economic, and landscape values, shaping the strong cultural identity of the region. Despite these values, it has been under decay over the last decades, indicating the inefficiency of current governance strategies. In this paper, we argue how three main discourses can be found that underpin different governance strategies in the montado: The heritage discourse, the modern production discourse, and the land stewardship discourse. These discourses frame farmers' decisions, though not always explicitly. The discourse analysis is grounded on an analysis of the relevant literature and research results from diverse projects, including an analysis of media representation of the montado since the 1990s, participatory observations, and 30 in-depth interviews with key stakeholders. Each of the three discourses identified are characterized in terms of key farming developments and defining elements, their time-scopes, the ways in which they are perceived by society, their measures of success, and underpinning institutions and power mechanisms. We argue that these discourses co-exist today, and this is a cause of increased tensions in montado governance strategies, hindering more effective and sustainable potential alternatives for the system.

AB - The montado is a silvo pastoral system, and the dominant land-use in the region of Alentejo (Portugal). It bears high nature, socio-economic, and landscape values, shaping the strong cultural identity of the region. Despite these values, it has been under decay over the last decades, indicating the inefficiency of current governance strategies. In this paper, we argue how three main discourses can be found that underpin different governance strategies in the montado: The heritage discourse, the modern production discourse, and the land stewardship discourse. These discourses frame farmers' decisions, though not always explicitly. The discourse analysis is grounded on an analysis of the relevant literature and research results from diverse projects, including an analysis of media representation of the montado since the 1990s, participatory observations, and 30 in-depth interviews with key stakeholders. Each of the three discourses identified are characterized in terms of key farming developments and defining elements, their time-scopes, the ways in which they are perceived by society, their measures of success, and underpinning institutions and power mechanisms. We argue that these discourses co-exist today, and this is a cause of increased tensions in montado governance strategies, hindering more effective and sustainable potential alternatives for the system.

KW - Discourse

KW - Governance

KW - Montado

KW - Multi-functionality

KW - Portugal

KW - Silvo-pastoral system

KW - Tension

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069772214&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3390/su11123363

DO - 10.3390/su11123363

M3 - Journal article

VL - 11

JO - Sustainability

JF - Sustainability

SN - 2071-1050

IS - 12

M1 - 3363

ER -